Garrett's Discovery
By Monday, Tobias had a plan and a shared doc titled PROJECT R-12, and by Tuesday he was standing in front of the senior class council pitching it, stripped of every detail that could point back to Elias by name. A staff member has been quietly covering student lunch debt for years, out of pocket, and is retiring in two weeks. We're going to pay it back—as a class gift, before he leaves.
Most of the room nodded along. Garrett Voss did not.
"You're asking us to fundraise for a rumor," Garrett said, arms crossed, varsity jacket zipped despite the room being warm. "No name, no proof, just 'trust me.' How do we know this isn't some story you made up to skip the actual senior gift committee, which by the way I'm on, and which already voted on a bench."
"It's not a rumor," Tobias said. "I've seen the ledger."
"Then show it."
Tobias couldn't, not without exposing Elias before he was ready—and Garrett knew it, which was exactly why he'd asked.
The meeting ended with half the room intrigued and half rolling their eyes, and Garrett cornering Tobias afterward in the hallway, not hostile exactly, more like a prosecutor circling a case he hadn't decided how to argue yet.
"I'll believe it when I see something real," Garrett said. "So I did some digging of my own. County property records. Voter roll. Basic stuff, nothing illegal."
"And?"
"Elias Thorne doesn't own a house. Doesn't rent an apartment either, not under his name. Far as I can tell, he's been living in a converted garage attached to his sister's place off Route 9 for the last five years." Garrett's voice had lost its edge somewhere in the last sentence, gone flatter, more careful. "And he's clocked overtime at a warehouse job three nights a week for at least that long. I checked the shift board through my dad's foreman buddy."
Tobias felt the floor tilt again, same as the newspaper clipping, same as the badge log lining up eleven times in a row.
"He's not just spending a little extra," Garrett said quietly. "He gave up having a place of his own to do this. And if we go public with his name before he's ready, and it comes out that the guy everyone's suddenly cheering for is sleeping in his sister's garage—"
He didn't finish the sentence. He didn't have to.
"We could humiliate him instead of honoring him," Tobias said.
Garrett nodded, and for the first time all week, he didn't look like a skeptic anymore. He looked like someone who'd just signed on.