What Mrs. Alden Remembers
Talia's face when she saw the clipping in Junie's hands looked like something breaking very slowly, the way ice cracks before it gives.
"Put that back," she said. Her voice wasn't angry. It was worse — flat, and scared.
"Mom, is that man my grandpa? Is Gideon my—"
"Put. It. Back." Talia crossed the attic in three steps and took the box from Junie's hands, gentle even in her panic, and closed it like closing a wound. "He's not who you think he is, Junie. He made choices. Bad ones. He hurt this family and then he disappeared for twenty-five years, and now you want to give him a coat like he's some — some stray dog you found."
"But he's my grandpa—"
"He is a stranger," Talia said, and there were tears standing in her eyes now, furious and unshed. "Go to your room. Please. I need to think."
Junie went. But she didn't stay.
She climbed out her bedroom window at dusk — not far, just down to the porch roof and along the gutter to the trellis, a route she'd mapped out months ago for exactly this kind of emergency — and crossed two lawns in the dark to Mrs. Alden's lit kitchen window.
Mrs. Alden let her in without a single question about the hour, which told Junie she'd been half-expecting this.
"Twenty-five years ago," Mrs. Alden said, settling into her chair with two mugs of cocoa, "Gideon Locke ran Locke Hardware with your great-grandfather. Good man. Everybody on this street bought their nails and their paint from him, and half of them bought it on credit he never chased them for." She stirred her cocoa slowly. "Then the books came up short. Nine thousand dollars, missing over two years. And the only other person who touched those books was Odette's brother — Roland Pike."
"So it was Roland? Not Gideon?"
"That's the thing nobody could ever prove," Mrs. Alden said, "because Gideon confessed. Signed a statement, pled guilty, went away for four years, and never once — not once, in the trial, not to a newspaper, not to his own wife as far as I know — said a single word to defend himself."
Junie sat frozen, cocoa cooling in her hands. "Why would he do that if he didn't do it?"
Mrs. Alden's eyes went distant, somewhere back in decades. "That," she said, "is the question I've been asking for twenty-five years. And Roland Pike — well. Roland Pike is the bank manager on Fifth Avenue now. Drives a very nice car for a man who started with nothing."
A knock came at Mrs. Alden's door — sharp, unexpected, three raps in the dark.
Mrs. Alden went pale. "That's not a neighborly hour," she murmured, and rose to answer it, leaving Junie's heart hammering against her ribs in the sudden quiet.